it's well known that I'm not a fan of Jerry Angelo and his draft record the last several years - its the primary reason why the Bears are falling apart in 2009.
But to illustrate the points further, I decided to break down the last 4 drafts and the Bears selections, followed by a similar positional player that was selected after the Bears pick.
While the Bears have undoubtedly whiffed more often than not - though they were not the only ones. It is slightly unfair to highlight the players selected after the Bears picks in that other teams made the same mistakes ... but obviously someone's scouting department hit it out of the park
note: I don't buy the "evaluate the draft 2-3 years after the fact. No. This is the NFL. Rookies are expected to produce. So yes, 2009 counts.
2009 - No 1st or 2nd Round picks so you can argue the Bears would not be able to get impact guys anyway, but the fact remains that only 2 of 9 picks have even seen the field. FAIL.
No. 68 - DT Jarron Gilbert
Has not played yet, which equals bust and any of these would have been better picks: DT Terrance Knighton (72), RB Glen Coffee (74), DT Roy Miller (81), WR Mike Wallace (84),
No. 99 - WR Juaquin Iglesias
No. 105 - DE Henry Melton
Neither has played yet, which equals bust and any of these would have been better picks:
WR Mike Thomas (107), WR Brian Hartline (108), OL T.J. Lang (109)
No. 119 - DB DJ Moore
Has not played yet, which equals bust and any of these would have been better picks:
WR Louis Murphy (124), WR Austin Collie (127)
No. 140 - WR Johnny Knox
Considered a "win" at this point...the only bright spot of this draft.
No. 154 - LB Marcus Freeman
Everyone else in this area has busted out thus far...so a wash..
No. 190 - DB Al Afalava
He is a starter, so this makes his selection a "win"
No. 246 - OL Lance Louis
No. 251 - WR Derek Kinder
Everyone else in this area has busted out thus far...so a wash..
2008 - mixed results at best, but quickly looking like another failure...
No. 14 - T Chris Williams
In a tackle heavy draft, the Bears picked a guy with known back problems. This forced him to sit out all of '08. Which makes all of these better picks - Gosder Cherilus (17), Jeff Otah (19), Duane Brown (26).
No. 44 - RB Matt Forte
It's hard to argue with the Rookie of the Year, especially with where he was picked. He's been bad this year, but I still lean toward a win for Angelo.
Passed on RB Ray Rice (55), Kevin Smith (64)
No. 70 - WR Earl Bennett
Didn't play at all as a rookie in 2008, which should make him an automatic bust. But only 2 wide receivers were picked after him - Early Doucet (81) and Harry Douglas (84). Also passed on RB Steve Slaton (89)
No. 90 - DT Marcus Harrison
Only one defensive tackle was taken after Harrison, which kind of means he's a "win."
No. 120 - DB Craig Steltz
No. 142 - DB Zackary Bowman
Not too many DBs were chosen after either of these picks, which either means they're a soft "wins" for the fact they're on the roster or again - they were over valued.
No. 158 - TE Kellen Davis
Only two tight ends were picked after Davis - Tom Santi (196) and Matt Sherry (207). Santi could be the heir apparent to Dallas Clark in Indy and Sherry never played in NFL. Minor win.
No. 208 - DE Ervin Baldwin
No. 222 - OL Chester Adams
Never played a down, which means any of these would have been better picks: FB Peyton Hillis (227), RB Justin Forsett (233).
No. 243 - LB Joey LaRoque
No. 247 - OL Kirk Barton
Never played a down - washes as no one drafted that low proved to be worth anything.
2007 - Total bust out for the Bears GM. Total.
No. 31 - TE Greg Olsen
passed on pass catchers: Anthony Gonzalez (32), Zach Miller (38), Sidney Rice (44), Steve Smith (51)
No. 62 - DE Dan Bazuin
* not only did Bazuin never play for the Bears, but here's the real interesting thing - only 2 defensive ends were picked between him and the Bears next pick that year at the end of the third round. And while Quentin Moses (65) and Charles Johnson (83) aren't exactly lighting the world on fire - they at least have played.
No. 93 - RB Garrett Wolfe
passed on running backs Michael Bush (100), Antonio Pittman (107)
No. 94 - LB Michael Okwo
- very similar to Bazuin in that he didn't play a down for the Bears. Only 2 linebackers were picked between Okwo & their next pick - Stephen Nicholas (109) and Zak DeOssie (116). Nicholas has played some, but again - what were the Bears scouts thinking?
No. 130 - OL Josh Beekman
No offensive linemen selected after Beekman have been as productive as the center/guard. Is projected as Olin Kreutz's replacement - and he has been OK as a guard - so let's call this mild victory for Angelo.
That said - players selected after Beekman include LB Clint Session (136), RB Le'Ron McClain (137), WR Steve Breaston (142), RB Kolby Smith (148), TE Kevin Boss (153), TE Dante Rosario (155), TE Brent Celek (162)
This fact alone makes Greg Olsen's selection in the 1st round even more of a bust. This was obviously a draft that had similar - if not better - players than Olsen much further down in the draft.
No. 167 - DB Kevin Payne
No. 168 - DB Corey Graham
These can be considered good picks by Angelo in the 5th round in that they've played quite a bit and no other DB selected between them and the Bears' next pick have produced as much.
In fact, the best players picked after them are kickers Nick Folk (178) and Mason Crosby (194). TE Ben Patrick (215) has been mildly productive.
No. 221 - DB Trumaine McBride
RB DeShawn Wynn (228) is probably the only player that has had more of an impact than McBride the last few years. Which isn't saying much...
No. 241 - OL Aaron Brant
- never played for Bears, which means any of these players would have been a better pick: RB Jason Snelling (244), RB Kenneth Darby (247), RB Ahmad Bradshaw (250), DB Nedu Ndukwe (253)